Quote: "God has a pattern into which all of our lives fit. His pattern requires that some lives be twisted, knotted, or cut short, while others extend to impressive lengths, not because one thread is more deserving than another, but simply because the pattern requires it. Looked at from underneath, from our vantage point in life, God’s pattern of reward and punishment seems arbitrary and without design, like the underside of a tapestry. But looked at from outside this life, from God’s vantage point, every twist and knot is seen to have its place in a great design that adds up to a work of art" (22).
1. The Class Opinion: While 13 classmates agree with the quote, 8 classmates disagree, and four raised questions or needed clarification about the text.
2. Kushner's Argument: "On closer examination, however, this approach is found wanting. For all its compassion, it too is based in large measure on wishful thinking."
"The crippling illness of a child, the death of a young husband and father, the ruin of an innocent person through malicious gossip—these are all real. We have seen them. But nobody has seen Wilder’s tapestry. All he can say to us is “Imagine that there might be such a tapestry.” I find it very hard to accept hypothetical solutions to real problems."
3. The Theological Implications: The theological implications from this quote support the idea that God is all-powerful, all-knowing being who has a predestined plan for each and every person on the planet. Additionally, this quote claims that God has complete control of our lives and gets to decide who suffers and when.
4. A Discussion Question: Does this quote imply that it does not matter who we are or how we act because our destiny has already been written out for us?
5. Media: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CV9nL_1GKJQ