Chapter 5
Everything's an Argument

žA fallacy is a hole in an argument. Fallacies are dangerous because they break down civil conversation and make arguments more difficult.

Some people who use fallacies probably do not realize they do it. Some people do it for the sole purpose of confusing and/or tripping up people. žAvoid fallacious reasoning in arguments.

Fallacies are grouped according to the appeals ethos, logos, and pathos.  

Chapter 5 outlines the most common fallacies, but thousands of fallacies exist.  For more information on fallacies, see the AP/CEP Symbaloo tiles on my webpage.  

Pathos Fallacies

žScare Tactics- An exaggeration on possible dangers beyond their statistical likelihood. These are dangerous because they close off rational thinking. People who are scared rarely act rationally.

What was the discussion we had about logos and numbers? What about other diseases/illnesses?  How many people die every day from pneumonia?  Car accidents?  Choking?  Heart attacks?  This is poster is dangerous because many people may associate anything from Africa as Ebola-ridden.  

Look at this poster:

Look at the size of the "widespread and intense transmission" on the map.  Now look at the rest of the map.  The horrors of Ebola spreading has been exaggerated because people rarely act or think rationally when they are scared.  Do you see the reality of this disease?  Even the numbers on the map tell a different story from the previous poster.

Either-Or- This fallacy only gives two options—one preferred over the other. No “gray areas." This is, basically, an ultimatum. Hardly anyone likes ultimatums.

Either-Or Fallacies are used to seduce those who do not know any better.

These become fallacious when they reduce a complicated issue to simple terms.

Overly Sentimental Appeal- These use tender emotions excessively to distract readers from the facts. Emotions become an impediment to rationality when they stop people from thinking clearly.

Read the following:

And here is the rational side (with fallacies included):

Bandwagon Appeal- Urges people to follow the same path. Rather than be independent, sometimes it’s easier to “get on board” with everyone else. The mentality of the bandwagon is that something has to be “DONE RIGHT NOW”!

Slippery Slope- Todays’ tiny misstep is tomorrow’s slide into disaster. The slippery slope, like the scare tactic fallacy, could be a statistical unlikelihood.

Ethos Fallacies

Appeals to False Authority- Writers offer themselves or others as authorities to support or believe a claim. X is true because I say so; What I say must be true. “Trust, but verify” comes in to play here. Always question the authority.

Dogmatism Fallacy- A writer expresses a particular position is the only one that is acceptable. No arguments are necessary and the truth is self-evident. Dogmatists believe people are rational and should believe what the writer believes.

Ad Hominem- Means “to the man” in Latin. This fallacy is an attack on the person or the person’s character rather than the argument. This is for the sole purpose of destroying someone’s credibility. These often turn into two-sided affairs with the good guys vs. the bad guys.

Logos Fallacies

Stacking the Deck- This happens when the arguer shows only one side of the story—the one in his/her favor. Be careful not to do this! You MUST consider the other side and admit you have no ulterior motives. If you fail to address the other side, you are setting yourself up for this fallacy.

“You know teenagers today: they are lazy, incompetent, druggies, criminals,” said the middle-aged employee to his elderly boss. (BTW, the middle-aged employee is vying for a promotion over a teenager and is “stacking the deck” in his favor.)

Hasty Generalization- A conclusion built on insufficient evidence: because my sister is dumb and is a blonde, ALL blondes and sisters are dumb. This fallacy is the basis for most stereotypes. Lady Macbeth uses this against Macbeth (as well as many other fallacies) when she said, “Screw you courage to the sticking place and we’ll not fail.”

To avoid this fallacy you MUST use QUALIFYING words: few, many, most, rarely, occasionally, possibly, in some cases, under certain circumstances, in my limited experience, etc.

Faulty Causality-Also known as Post Hoc, Ergo Prompter Hoc = after this, because of this. This fallacy leads others to believe that one event caused the second.

Example-A writer sued the Coors beer company claiming his consumption of vast amounts of Coors beer prevented him from writing a novel. (He didn’t win, by the way.)

The commercial claims a roughneck street thug will be a better person just by drinking a Coke.  The cause of the thug's good mood?  Drinking a Coke.  Faulty Causality fallacy is similar to Non Sequitur because "it is not as simple as it is presented."

Begging the Question- This is also known as Circular Reasoning. This claim literally goes in a circle and cannot be disputed: this cannot be questioned.

Example-You can’t give me a C in this class because I am an A student. So, an A student can never earn a C (and vice versa).

Example-Manning would never throw the Super Bowl because he’s an honest person. So, an honest person would never do anything dishonest (and vice-versa).

Equivocation- A half truth or double meaning. These are tricks of language. Macbeth curses the witches’ predictions when he realizes he has believed “half truths”: “…to doubt the equivocation of the fiend that lies like truth.”

Example- A plagiarist who copies a paper word for word from another declares, “I wrote that paper myself!”

Example- “Do you have any change?” “No, I don’t.” (But he has a $20.00 bill.)

The audience has two interpretations of the players.  If the audience listens closer, two different conversations are occurring, but the words used have different meanings.

And the most infamous equivocation.....

Non Sequitur- Does not follow. Does not connect. I call this the “Is it really that simple?” fallacy. In a non sequitur, a step is omitted or a sequence of two unrelated events is stated.

Is "loving your life" as easy as going to Curves for 30 minutes every other day?  Steps are left out: diet, additional exercise, lifestyle change, sleeping more, natural supplements, etc.

Red Herring- A distraction. This comes from the act of dragging a dried red herring fish across the path of the fox to throw the hounds off the trail. A red herring occurs when someone tries to “distract” the audience from the topic.

Even cartoons know the infamous red herring:

Faulty Analogy- An inaccurate comparison. Comparisons are useful but when they are pushed too far—stretched too far—they become inaccurate comparisons. Example-A president who has no military experience will not make a good president—that is the same as electing a passerby on the street to be president.

How about this commercial:

The Straw Man- Attacking an argument that is not strong or non-existent.  The arguer may make the argument stronger or more extreme than it really is.  

Example: Women are physically weaker than men, so they need protection and for men to lead them.  This is why women do not receive more pay for the jobs they do.

The above is attacking a small argument (women are physically weaker) and making it a larger aspect of the wage war argument.

Typical Straw Man

"Obama may not be eloquent, but he is glib and clever and at times persuasive.  One of his favorite rhetorical devices is setting up a straw man, then knocking it down.  He invoked this classic ploy subtly in his inaugural address, crudely in his press conference. 'We will restore science to its rightful place," Obama said at his inauguration.  Really? Where had science been? 'We are ready to lead once more,' he said, as if we--America--hadn't been.  He may have disapproved of the prior administration's policies in the world, but that doesn't mean it wasn't leading.  Also in his inaugural speech, Obama said, 'we can no longer afford indifference to suffering outside our borders.' When were we indifferent? Not in Obama's lifetime." --Fred Barnes, "Obama's First Month"

And the Most Infamous Fallacy:

The Fallacy Fallacy- Being too eager to find fallacies in an argument.  Be careful whipping out fallacies on someone.  Be sure the person has committed a fallacy.  Be humble if you are wrong and admit you are incorrect.

On That Note...

Fallacies are holes in reasoning.  They impede rational arguments.  Do not use them in arguments.  Be nice when pointing out fallacies in others' arguments.  No one wants an ad hominem argument thrown on the table.